Saturday, February 20, 2016

The End of Money

What is money? It turns out economists don't have a terribly rigorous definition for it; there's no consensus definition of money beyond the old tripartate "medium of exchange," "medium of account," "medium of storage" baloney, which neatly avoids defining medium (which I thought was the whole point). You can take the modern-physics point of view that matter (mass) cannot, itself, be defined, except through its interactions and behaviors. Hence, money should not have to be defined except through its behaviors. Which is fine and good, except that modern economics, with its Rube Goldberg mathematics, is (unlike physics) pretty much a pile of shit when it comes to predicting anything worth knowing. Economics is not physics.

The usual childish way of "explaining" money is to point out that before money, trade had to be conducted in terms of barter. This fairy tale overlooks the fact that no important economy in human history was ever barter-based, and coins (which date to maybe 700 BCE) are a fairly late development. The Egyptians, Sumerians, and others (e.g., South American cultures) had extensive "systems of account" long before coins were invented. The concept of accountable wealth was already quite old, in fact, when this curious thing known as money appeared.

Steve Roth does an excellent job of summarizing the poor state of "what we know about money" in his fine post Did Money Evolve? You Might (Not) Be Surprised, which I won't try to recap here. One of the key contributions of Roth's article comes at the very beginning, when he points out:
[E]xchange, trade, reciprocity, tit for tat, and associated notions of “fairness” and “just deserts” have deep roots in humans’ evolutionary origins. We see expressions of these traits in capuchin monkeys and chimps (researchers created a “cash economy” where chimps were trained to exchange inedible tokens for food, then their trading behaviors were studied), in human children as young as two, in domestic dogs, and even in corvids — ravens and crows.
This gets to the heart of the matter, because money does seem to be a uniquely human abstraction of the much larger, more universal notion of reciprocal behavior seen in other species. It's an abstraction that relies on concepts of numeracy, atomicity, equivalence (something can be a token for something else), and social exchange. It's a method of account for reciprocity, an acknowledgement that fairnesss can be ratified mathematically. Money is simply the artifact that embodies these principles—principles of accountable fairness.

So if we put our sociological hats on (recognizing that money is inherently a social construct; it makes no sense to have money if no one else is around), and if we understand money as a system of account for reciprocity, it's somewhat easier to understand the rise of democracy in ancient Greece (coming around the same time, and in the same place, as the invention of coins); it's easier to understand the emergence of capitalism (and its association with the emergence of paper money); and it's also somewhat easier to comprehend the current deterioration of democracy (which I write about all the time in this blog), and rise in inequality, as a delapidation of fairness, economically expressed, culminating—surprise!—in all the recent chatter about the need to ban cash.

As Western society (the capitalist democracies, now taken over by corporate elites) lets slip the basic principles of fairness upon which it was founded, it's no surprise that we see story after story about the supposed desirability of eliminating currency. Cash is the ultimate symbol of reciprocity, but there is nothing reciprocal or symmetric or fair in what the owner class has in mind for the underclasses. We should not even demand to be paid! We should simply give all wealth to the owners, and let them take care of us as they see fit. This is the constant message of Wall Street, the Koch brothers, the GOP, and yes, even the Democratic techno-elite (aptly represented by the Clintons). They want it all. They won't be satisfied until the top 0.1% own and control all wealth, at which point (obviously) it makes no sense, any longer, for anyone to have "money."


  1. You make excellent points. This is why we will see (within our lifetimes)the change from value placed on 'things' (money) to value placed on people. Abstracts like money will no longer be necessary once we realize 'things' have no value. Like it or not, we do not own 'land' or 'gold' or anything else. We didn't create it, so it is not for us to 'own' it or charge other people for having it or living on it. It is the contributions of people that holds the true wealth.

  2. We just not transport your goods, we do full management for your relocation and make it a pleasant experience for you. Packers and Movers in Pune takes his job seriously and honesty to do what best for customers, that has made us reliable and recommended Domestic packing and moving service provider in Pune and other major cities in India.
    Packers and Movers in Mumbai
    list of packers and movers in pune
    Movers and Packers in Kalyani Nagar
    Movers and Packers in Pimple Gurav
    Movers and Packers in Nigdi
    Movers and Packers in Ravet
    movers and packers in hyderabad
    packers and movers in hyderabad charges

  3. If you are struggling to produce a pefect analysis essay according to the requirements given by your professor, you may need qualified essay support. Here you can get inormation how to do an analysis essay.


  5. Hello Everyone !

    USA SSN Leads/Dead Fullz available, along with Driving License/ID Number with good connectivity.

    All SSN's are Tested & Verified.



    *Price for SSN lead $2
    *You can ask for sample before any deal
    *If you buy in bulk, will give you discount
    *Sampling is just for serious buyers

    ->Hope for the long term business
    ->You can buy for your specific states too

    **Contact 24/7**

    Whatsapp > +923172721122

    Email >

    Telegram > @leadsupplier

    ICQ > 752822040

  6. As one of the leading online nursing dissertation writing help, we assist the students so that they do not feel stuck in their dissertation. We possess versatile knowledge and expertise in drafting a nursing thesis.

  7. British Dissertation Consultants provides effective and detailoriented dissertation proofreading services of your dissertation to ensure that your dissertation is globally acceptable.

  8. This is what I get on that page, Nice Post and Appreciated your support. Thank you so much for sharing such a detailed information. We are proud that clients hold against using our moving company.
    Furniture Movers and packers like make their best handling to secure the goods from all the possible effects.
    Professional furniture Moving and packing service Sharjah, at reasonable price.

  9. Hi Guy's

    Fresh & valid spammed USA SSN+Dob Leads with DL available in bulk.

    >>1$ each SSN+DOB
    >>2$ each with SSN+DOB+DL
    >>5$ each for premium (also included relative info)

    Prices are negotiable in bulk order
    Serious buyer contact me no time wasters please
    Bulk order will be preferable

    Telegram > @leadsupplier
    ICQ > 752822040
    Email >


    SSN+DOB Fullz
    CC's with CVV's (vbv & non-vbv)
    USA Photo ID'S (Front & back)

    All type of tutorials available
    (Carding, spamming, hacking, scam page, Cash outs, dumps cash outs)

    SMTP Linux Root
    DUMPS with pins track 1 and 2
    Socks, rdp's, vpn's
    Server I.P's
    HQ Emails with passwords

    Looking for long term business
    For trust full vendor, feel free to contact

    Telegram > @leadsupplier
    ICQ > 752822040
    Email >

  10. Mizoram Board HSLC Model Paper 2022, MBSE HSLC New Question Paper 2022,, Mizoram Board 10th Class Question Paper 2022, Mizoram Board of School Education will lead High School Leaving Certificate HSLC/10th tests in March 2022. Huge quantities of competitors are relied upon to show up in this assessment. So they all are looking on to get Mizoram Board HSLC Model Paper 2022. So news is that MBSE will distribute test MBSE HSLC New Question Paper January 2022. Applicants will soon ready to download Question Paper 2022 from true site of MBSE. Mizoram 10th Model Paper MBSE HSLC Exam Previous Question Paper 2022 subtleties are refreshed here for reference. Allude Mizoram 10th Latest Question Paper 2022 preceding making an investigation arrangement. Follow MBSE HSLC/10th Class Previous Question Paper 2022 download steps. Likewise, realize the Mizoram Board HSLC Question Paper 2022 delivery date. Check the beneath modules to get expected MBSE Class 10 Exam Previous Question Paper 2022 alongside Preparation Tips. Mizoram 10th Class Question Paper 2022 MBSE HSLC Previous Question Paper 2022


Add a comment. Registration required because trolls.