Friday, April 03, 2009

Twitter, Google, and Semantic RSS

TechCrunch is reporting that the rumors about Google being in talks to acquire Twitter are true. Naturally, everybody wants to analyze this along "search" dimensions. TechCrunch says Twitter is about "people searching for news" and "brands searching for feedback." But that hardly conveys the importance of what's going on.

Talking about Twitter using the language of "search" feels vaguely wrong, like force-fitting a 20th-century semantic facade over a 21st-century idea. Imagine that the iPod were to have appeared in 1970, when handheld transistor radios were "high tech." People would have talked about the iPod in transistor-radio terms, instead of understanding it in terms of personal empowerment and cultural shift. The same is true of Twitter. It's more than a new data stream.

I spent most of this week at the AIIM show in Philadelphia, and while I was there, I was talking to an acquaintance about Twitter, trying to explain what makes Twitter so revolutionary for me. Bear in mind, until two months ago, I was not a Twitter user and never imagined I would be one.

I talked about bookmarks and how, originally, bookmarks were a hugely empowering idea: You could choose to keep references, in your browser, to parts of the Web that have special to you. But bookmarks became useless to me when I accumulated so many of them that I couldn't find the ones I wanted or (in many cases) even remember why I made many of them.

A few minutes ago, I counted how many bookmarks I have in my browser. You can do this, too. If you have Firefox, use the Import and Backup toolbar command in the Organize Bookmarks dialog to export your bookmarks as HTML:

Open the resulting HTML document in your browser, then run the following one-line script in the console:


When I ran this script a few minutes ago, I learned that I have 598 bookmarks. That's beyond my ability to manage. It means bookmarks are useless to me now.

All is not lost, though, because I've found (in the meantime) that Google and RSS feeds are more useful. Google acts as a kind of just-in-time bookmark, or at least an indirection to bookmarks. RSS feeds are dynamically-updating bookmarks (in a sense), which is also a good thing.

But now I have too many RSS feeds! I can't easily scan them all. Much of what I want to "keep track of" on the Web (in terms of news blog entries of interest to me, and industry news) is no longer easily trackable. What I really need is some kind of intelligent filtering process that runs in the background and keeps a list of semantically relevant items, so I can just find the things of interest to me. New things. Up-to-date things.

Why not use Google news alerts? you may ask. Short answer: Poor signal-to-noise ratio. I get too many "false positives." Google news alerts are not "smart." The software that produces them is quite naive and easily fooled by stories that match the vocabulary of my search query. That's not what I want.

What does any of this have to do with Twitter?

Twitter is where I find out about industry news and new blog posts of potential interest to me. When an important news story breaks, I find out about it on Twitter first, and I usually know about it before any of my non-Twitter friends.

As for keeping up with relevant blog posts: The people I follow on Twitter share my interests. They tweet links to blog posts. The links tend to be extraordinarily useful and (again) extremely up-to-date. Much better than a "dumb list" of RSS feeds.

Twitter thus represents, for me, a semantically filtered super-RSS feed. It's very far from perfect, of course, but when I balance the time I spend sifting through 140-char tweets with the time I would otherwise spend walking RSS-feed links, doing searches in Google, waiting for full pages to load at various web sites, etc., I find that I actually save a lot of time by following Twitter streams.

Tweets represent semantically filtered information. A person with interests similar to mine has already determined that something is useful enough to share. That's the most valuable kind of semantic filtering there is.

Even without a "semantic web" of RDF triples and linked data and all the rest, I have an ad-hoc semantic web to work from, in Twitter. And it's up-to-the-minute. Twitterstreams move at the speed of the Web.

If I follow a Twitter Search as RSS, I'm even further ahead of the game.

So if Google acquires Twitter (which they will, if they're smart), Google doesn't just acquire a new data stream to build crummy little beta-apps on top of. It acquires a new paradigm. That's the true significance of Twitter. That, in a nutshell, is why they will acquire Twitter.


  1. "#aiim09 wireless reception in exhibit hall seems v. weak, many dropped connections."

    "#aiim09 exhibit hall kinda died yesterday afternoon. Everyone went to sessions."

    "#aiim09 Foot traffic this morning looks fairly strong in the exhibit hall."

    "@irina_guseva Awesome. You rock!"

    "@adriaanbloem I wonder if you can crowdsource a Mona Lisa."

    Just some selections from your recent tweets… why would google buy this shit? are you fucking delusional this garbage is worthless, just endless databases full of crap like I have posted above. If google pay money for this they may as well pay money for radio static, they have about the same value.


  2. lol at the above comment. It's true: I do think you're overstating the usefulness of Twitter slightly... It's far from a list of insanely useful links to really interesting and relevant pages. It's mainly just hot air.

  3. It seems ~6 million people disagree with you.

  4. Anonymous3:20 PM

    I enjoy Twitter, but it could never replace Google Reader.

    Have you tried Reader?

  5. The answer to too much content is better filters, not worse content.

  6. Anonymous10:21 AM

    Excellent blog post! Between Google Reader and Twitter, I feel connected to the news of technology!

  7. Nice blog…thanks for sharing…its very interesting…
    i’m searching for this information from long time…

  8. I admire the valuable advice you make available in your expertly written content. I want to thank you for this informative read; I really appreciate sharing this great.Packers And Movers Bhopal
    Packers And Movers Seoni
    Packers And Movers Shahdol

  9. Packers and Movers in Delhi - The Air cargo Packers & Logistics was incorporated to offer remarkable services to its reputable clients. Capitalizing on our experience and expertise in the field of packaging and unloading , we are providing our specialized services across India and that's why you will face no problem with our services.

  10. Icon Cargo Packers & Movers are offering outstanding packing and moving services in almost all the major cities of India. Are you seeking for Packers and Movers in Palam Vihar, Gurgaon. Then you may contact icon cargo packers for a hassle free transportation.

  11. Hey Guys !

    USA Fresh & Verified SSN Leads AVAILABLE with best connectivity
    All Leads have genuine & valid information

    First Name | Last Name | SSN | Dob | DL Number |Address | State | City | Zip | Phone Number | Account Number | Bank NAME

    *Price for SSN lead $2
    *You can ask for sample before any deal
    *If anyone buy in bulk, we can negotiate
    *Sampling is just for serious buyers

    ->$5 PER EACH

    ->Hope for the long term deal
    ->Interested buyers will be welcome

    **Contact 24/7**
    Whatsapp > +923172721122
    Email >
    Telegram > @leadsupplier
    ICQ > 752822040

  12. Are you thinking about SEO Services? Seo Rank Agency is the best seo services Provider in india. We provide SEO,SMO,PPC,Web Design and Website Development services at affordable prices with 100% satisfaction.Call at 8287878854.No1 Seo services providers company in India offering the best SEO solutions to Archive top Ranking and 10x your Business sales With a team of top seo specialist india, Best Seo plans.Looking for Social Media Marketing Services in India.

  13. We sell the best counterfeit banknotes! Buy fake euro notes online at our shop with fast worldwide delivery. We offer good quality and cheap
    Contact us for more info and price list.

  14. If you have plans to visit the UK, it is essential to consult with professional and
    highly skilled immigration solicitors UK. This is so, as the knowledge and expertise
    of such professionals can increase your chances of getting the visa.
    However, most of the people have some misconceptions about the fee charged by these solicitors.
    People do believe that immigration lawyers charge heavily for their services. This might be
    true to some extent, but most of the top-rated service providers charge a reasonable fee.
    To guide further, we have discussed this matter in a comprehensive manner. We hope that
    after going through the content, your perception would change to a great extent.

    Visit Site:

  15. Tuck Front Boxes are considered to be very popular and useful by their very nature and people find it incredibly useful.

  16. Sanderstead Mini Cabs Taxis are one in all the most professional private Hire firms in South Croydon, covering All of Croydon and surrounding Areas for more than 30 years.
    We are a Fixed charge - NO terrible Fare after mind night and we are open 24/7, every day 365 days a year.We cover all Airports like Gatwick,Heathrow,Luton,London City ,Stansted Airport with in a minimal price Hurry up book your taxi call 02086862777 also reach our website.


Add a comment. Registration required because trolls.