Sunday, May 17, 2009

WolframAlpha fails to impress

I been fooling around with WolframAlpha (the much-ballyhooed intelligent search engine) yesterday and today, and all I can say is, it feels very alpha.

I tried every query I could think of to get the annual consumption of electricity in the U.S., and got nowhere. On the other hand, if you just enter "electricity," your first hit is Coulomb's law 2.0mC, 5.0mC, 250cm, your second hit is 12A, 110V, and your third hit is diode 0.6 V. Which seems (how shall I say?) pretty useless.

As it turns out, WolframAlpha is also extraordinarily slow most of the time and hasn't performed well in load tests. Apparently Wolfram's AI doesn't extend to figuring out how to make something scale.

I'll suspend judgment on WA for a while longer, pending further testing. But right now it looks and smells like the answer to a question nobody asked.

29 comments:

  1. It's always risky putting something out in alpha form. The possible queries outweigh the supported queries, so we are always going to have cases (lots of them) where something we want isn't answered. So tinkering is required with the query and the knowledge.

    In spite of that, I do think it is an intriguing tool - not one that will be my default search engine yet, however.

    In some domains it is delightful (weather being the most obvious), and in others it simply doesn't know anything.

    Does it have any links/relationships with CYC, I wonder?

    As far as scalability is concerned, that will become a huge issue if/when it goes mainstream. The amount of compute power required for a relatively complex google query will be minute compared with one of these. If we hazard a guess (and I have no data, just trying a number to see) that a wolframalpha query takes 2 orders of magnitude more compute power than a google query of similar complexity, then the production wolframalpha operation will cause the lights to dim in a major city.

    I'll definitely play with it some more though.....

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm not sure I understood right, but "annual electricity consumption US" gives "3.892 trillion kilowatt hours per year (2007 estimate)" straight away, is this what you were looking for?

    Also, they announced they are preforming load tests right now during the weekend. Friday was a soft launch, serious business comes on Monday I think.

    ReplyDelete
  3. True, there are still gaps in its apparent knowledge. The demo videos were spectacular, it will probably take a while to live up to those in typical performance.
    Worfram did say it was a long term project.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Of course it fails to impress: it's an advanced calculator touted by bloggers and press as being a google/wikipedia killer. It difficult to use it properly when you don't even know what it really is.

    Also, I wonder... is "Alpha" the product's name or is it supposed to mean that it's not even in beta yet?

    ReplyDelete
  5. http://www10.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=US+Electricity+consumption

    It wasn't that hard ...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous5:25 PM

    Heh, like the above comments state, your blog fails to impress.

    I mean, aren't you the same person who doesn't know how to interview without sounding like a sarcastic jackass?

    Based on this blog's content, you should definitely be checking for AssertionErrors, man. Stuart Grimshaw's comment is a great example of why.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Let's wait and see then shall we? Once it is up to it's full operational capacity, it would be interesting to see how it performs. Being touted as a Google or Wikipedia killer will bring about high expectations. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  8. เล่นง่ายได้เยอะ เครดิตฟรี สล็อต โจ๊กเกอร์ slot online ที่นี่คลิก
    https://www.slotxd.com/jokergaming123

    ReplyDelete
  9. Wow very informative article i like it and much thanks for sharing such topic about WolframAlpha fails to impress.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Custom Boxes World would be the box packaging makers offering customized multiple box packaging that satisfy your branding advertising and packaging demands. Custom Boxes Wholesale

    ReplyDelete
  11. Searching for Custom Printed 15ml Bottle Packaging Boxes to enrich your product appearance We offer low MOQ end to end solutions from design to shipping.
    15ml dropper boxes

    ReplyDelete
  12. Good blog thanks for sharing the information.
    Book box company
    Belt box company

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great job! Your article is so informative. I really like it.
    please read this
    Custom Boxes Wholesale

    ReplyDelete
  14. Cosmetic organizations create excellence arrangements of uniquely shaped custom bath bomb boxes. We give you’re possess made to display your image subject lineup. Uniquely shaped bath bomb box

    ReplyDelete
  15. Custom Boxes World is among the printing and boxes Supplier Company from the USA. We have served our clientele using our boxes that were created attractive. essential oil bottle packaging

    ReplyDelete
  16. Custom Boxes World would be the soap packaging makers offering customized soap packaging. It satisfies your branding advertising and packaging demands. wholesale soap packaging

    ReplyDelete
  17. Such a really nice post you shared with us. Thanks!
    Kraft boxes

    ReplyDelete
  18. Really good to see this amazing post. Thanks!
    Kraft boxes

    ReplyDelete
  19. Your blog is very frinedly.I really like if can you write on black mailer boxes.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Beautifully designed custom presentation boxes are the best tool to market your product. So, using customized boxes wholesale helps you in grabbing customer's attention.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Great post I like it very much keep up the good work. Read my blog CBD Boxes.

    ReplyDelete
  22. The third benefit that you can enjoy from using custom printed pillow boxes is that they are affordable. These custom printed boxes are made of high-quality cardboard and are available at a lower price. The boxes are lightweight, so you can use them in numerous ways. You can use them for placing gifts in, storing handbags, or shipping gifts. If you want to maximize your profits, you can create a website and sell them online.https://globalcustomboxes.com/

    ReplyDelete
  23. The music lovers not only pay attention to the collection of songs and the bands but they should also take the place of the concert in the account before their concert as the music is typically concerned with fun, entertainment, and poetry.https://alexmaxband.com/5-top-concert-places-in-the-world/

    ReplyDelete
  24. As the COVID-19 is spreading fast in the whole globe and it is getting severe day by day. So, the foremost concern of all and one is to prevent themselves from this pandemichttps://blueskyinn.org/how-to-protect-yourself-from-covid-19/

    ReplyDelete
  25. Nice and very helpful article, Thanks for sharing with us. Visit profile

    ReplyDelete
  26. Cream boxes are a popular item among brides and grooms. There are many traditional creams packaging boxes that you could purchase in order to match the theme of your wedding. Themed boxes are available to match wedding themes, and could even be purchased to coordinate with your wedding colors! If you have a themed wedding, consider purchasing custom-made cream boxes to match. Not only will it help you create an elegant look, but it may also leave your bride and groom (or whoever is getting married) with lots of extra storage space!

    ReplyDelete

Add a comment. Registration required because trolls.