Friday, March 08, 2013

Wheat and Schizophrenia

A number of people, knowing that my partner Sally has schizophrenia, have suggested that we look into the relationship between schizophrenia and wheat gluten. I decided to do a quick survey of the literature. Here's a recap of what I've found so far.
Wheat: Bringer of disease?

First of all, know that I'm a skeptic. Whenever somebody tells me wheat gluten is evil for this or that reason, I nod knowingly but politely, the way I nod knowingly but politely at Jehovah's Witnesses who come to my door; then I excuse myself with one of the rejoinders listed here.

But I'm also open-minded enough, and just plain curious enough, to look into such things before I dismiss them totally. It turns out a growing body of evidence has implicated the gliadin family of proteins (present in grains of the Triticum family) in a variety of atopic and inflammatory disease processes. The gliadins (of which there are three main types) stimulate production of the human protein zonulin, which mediates permeability of the intestines, through mechanisms that are just now being elucidated. "Leaky gut," in turn, is known to be a factor in autoimmune diseases. (As one researcher puts it: "When the zonulin pathway is deregulated in genetically susceptible individuals, autoimmune disorders can occur.") See this 2009 paper in PNAS as well as this 2011 paper for examples of recent work in this fast-moving area. For more citations, go here.

Zonulin research has direct application to such diverse ailments as diabetes, celiac disease, multiple sclerosis, and rheumatoid arthritis, and there is reason to believe autism and schizophrenia may in some way, in some individuals, be influenced by defects in zonulin metabolism. For example, we know that schizophrenia sufferers are at increased risk for celiac disease, and indeed in a 2011 study involving 1401 schizophrenia patients (and 900 controls) it was found: 
Among schizophrenia patients, 23.1% had moderate to high levels of IgA-AGA compared with 3.1% of the comparison group (χ2 = 1885, df = 2, P < .001.)
English translation: IgA, or immunoglobulin A, plays a critical role in mucosal immunity and is secreted in large amounts in the intestinal tract (in normal individuals). AGA refers to gliadin proteins. Elevated production of IgA antibodies in response to gliadin is characteristic of celiac disease (in fact, the gliadin antibody test is a mainline diagnostic tool in detecting the condition).

So where do we stand with regard to wheat and schizophrenia? The study cited more than any other on this subject is Dohan and Grasberger, "Relapsed schizophrenics: earlier discharge from the hospital after cereal-free, milk-free diet," Am J Psychiatry, 1973 Jun;130(6):685-8. You won't find the full PDF online, but I obtained a copy of it, so I'll summarize. The essence of it (as stated in the Abstract) is:
Routinely treated schizophrenics, who on admission were randomly assigned to a diet free of cereal grains and milk while on the locked ward, were discharged from the hospital about twice as rapidly as control patients assigned to a high-cereal diet. Wheat gluten secretly added to the cereal-free diet abolished this effect. These and previous findings suggest that cereal grains may be pathogenic for those hereditarily predisposed to schizophrenia just as they are for celiac disease, a disorder that may be genetically related.
The 115 study subjects were male veterans at the Coatesville, PA, Veterans Administration Hospital (average age 38) who met the description of schizophrenia in the original 1952 DSM-I. (Exactly why the VA hospital was using an out-of-date version of the DSM, I'm not sure. DSM-II was available at the time of the study.) Patients were randomly assigned either to a diet free of all cereal grains and milk products, or to the usual milk-containing hospital diet, which (for the experiment) "was made somewhat higher in cereal grains (e.g., spaghetti instead of potatoes)." Milk was omitted from from the cereal-free diet "because it produces a relapse in some celiac patients and thus, we hypothesized, may be harmful to some schizophnenics."

The study tracked the number of patients discharged from the hospital each 30 days for a period of 360 days. Discharge readiness of patients was apparently determined "after review of their cases at a staff conference." Unfortunately, the vagueness of this part of the protocol does raise serious questions about blinding and possible researcher bias. There's no indication of whether the authors of the paper themselves had a hand in determining discharge readiness. Another serious weakness of the study is that we don't know exactly which patients got how much of what medicines. All the authors say is: "Chlorpromazine and thionidazine were the most frequently administered antischizophrenic medications." We also learn, in the Discussion portion of the paper, that patients received the cereal-free/milk-free (CFMF) diet only during the portion of their stay when they were confined to a locked ward, which was "usually" 15 days. (According to the authors, 76% of the CFMF group got the restricted diet for 15 days, total, before going back on an unrestricted diet.)

I took the paper's tabular results and made a graph (below) from the numbers in Table 2. The graph shows days until release at the bottom and percent of patients released on the y-axis. You can see that the difference in release rates was highest in the first 90 days, then the curves for the two diet groups start to come together.

Data from: Dohan and Grasberger, "Relapsed schizophrenics:
earlier discharge from the hospital after cereal-free,
milk-free diet,"
Am J Psychiatry, 1973 Jun;130(6):685-8
I've looked at a number of other studies on gluten restriction and schizophrenia. They all suck in one way or another, whether in study design or (more often) the number of study subjects. The most interesting study I found was a controlled double-blind study of 24 patients involving the use of a gluten-free diet for 14 weeks. It found "there were beneficial changes in the whole group of [schizophrenic] patients between pre-trial and gluten-free period in five dimensions of the PIP (Psychotic In-Patient profile), maintained during the gluten challenge period," but the authors also admitted that the "changes could be attributed to the attention the patients received." (I'm not sure, but I think that last part means the study might have been invalid.)

One of the studies I looked at (that reported remarkable results) was basically a case study of a single patient. Another study, with the lofty title "Effects of Gluten on Schizophrenics," reported: "Thirteen schizophrenics were given gluten-free peanut-flour supplementary cookies and 13 were given virtually identical cookies with gluten added. Tests and rating scales before and after the ten-day study period showed no greater improvement for those receiving the gluten-free cookies than for those receiving the gluten-added cookies." From this, the authors of course concluded that gluten restriction is not at all beneficial, completely overlooking the fact that peanut cookies are not exactly hypo-allergenic. Recipe considerations aside, are we to decide an issue as complex as the role of gliadins in schizophrenia on the basis of just 13 people eating some cookies? I for one consider this kind of "study" a pathetic waste of research dollars.

Bottom line, research on the role of wheat in schizophrenia is hardly what you'd consider strong. The studies are sloppily designed, poorly controlled, use ridiculously small numbers of study subjects, employ crude methods of monitoring patient progress, etc. (yet of course they apply sound statistical methods to the numbers to make them look like solid science). The papers I saw wouldn't make good science-fair projects. All of them were laughably poor in one respect or another.

On the other hand, I can't claim to have read every single study that's ever been done in this area. Perhaps you'd like to dig into this yourself? If so, start with some of the references mentioned here. (And leave a comment below if you find something interesting.)

In the meantime, what I feel comfortable saying at this point is that it's way too early to rule out any role for gluten, zonulin, intestinal permeability, etc., in the pathogenesis of schizophrenia. I remain hopeful that good work in this area will come along sooner or later, and we'll eventually see some interesting results. For now, though, the science is pathetically weak. I don't think we dare draw any firm conclusions yet.

11 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dorian Roark3:05 PM

    I never knew that Grain can cause health issues. Learn something new everyday.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous12:26 PM

    Very interesting! Just found this, as my little sister has been recently diagnosed with Schizophrenia. A doctor had recommended cutting wheat and grain from her diet, as it was suppose to increase the intensity of her 'fits'. I decided to look into it more. Thanks for the great article :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous3:43 PM

    My sister has had schizophrenia for 20 + years. 6 months ago went on a gluten free diet and the change has been breathtaking and inspiring. Her symptoms are completely stabilized and her doctor has started lowering her medication. Her flare ups occur only when she cheats on her diet and resolve after a couple of days. I think the 20% or so schizophrenics with elevated AGA-IGA antibodies could benefit from a gluten free diet. Hopefully someone will do a study involving a cohort of high AGA-IGA patients. Then we could have some meaningful results. i agree i thought the peanut cookie study was pathetic. I think the Dohan studies were interesting but suffered from not having looking at the AGA aspect. It may be worth a shot to have your wife tested for AGA-IGA and if high then try the GFD. Here are a few links to studies I have found:

    http://www.bmlab.no/images/Marketing/Analyser/Aglutenfreedietinpeoplewithschizophrenia_SchizophreniaResearch140.pdf

    http://archive.hshsl.umaryland.edu/bitstream/10713/2905/1/(tTG)6%20DDW%202012%20Debbie%20final.pdf

    http://schizophreniabulletin.oxfordjournals.org/content/37/1/94.full.pdf+html

    Nothing great but interesting. Hopefully we get some better studies soon. Problem is no money in a gluten free diet so drug companies won't do anything.

    Cheers!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous11:54 AM

    I was diagnosed with schizoaffective and had weird immune problems right around the time that I started to develop symptoms (around 16 years old). I once read somewhere that it is common for autoimmune illnesses to develop around that age, so that is why a lot of researchers believe schizophrenia is an autoimmune disease. I also had othe health problems later on. After being diagnosed, antipsychotics did little for me. It was only until I removed wheat and sugar from my diet that I got better. I think it's important to cut out both wheat and sugar because they both affect the dopamine receptors in your brain, and schizophrenia symptoms are believed to be caused by an excess of dopamine. My dad also had food allergies/intolerances at an early age and suffered from major mental health problems. There is also a guy that wrote the book "Wheat Belly" that stated that modern wheat has more and more amounts of gliadin in it, and I think that there are a small amount of people (like those with autism and schizophrenia) that are highly susceptible to that. I also think that the human body was simply not meant to handle the large amounts of sugar that people eat today. In addition to being diagnosed with schizoaffective, I was also diagnosed with high-functioning autism earlier, and I think that there is a strong correlation in the immune problems that people with autism and people with schizophrenia experience.

    ReplyDelete

  6. I receive hundreds of fitness questions every day from people all over the world, but by far one of the most common themes in these questions revolve around the struggles that most people are having with losing that flabby stomach fat that doesn't seem to want to go away no matter what they try.

    Just recently I had the pleasure of meeting a fellow fitness professional named Mike Geary of TruthAboutAbs.com (insert aff link). Now Mike is a well-known expert who deals exclusively with the most effective strategies for losing stomach fat so that you can finally uncover those elusive six pack abs that everyone desires.

    Some of Mike's strategies deal with nutrition aspects and others deal with training techniques, but I was impressed to see that Mike has put together one of the most comprehensive resources for dealing with all of the aspects necessary to finally get rid of that nasty belly fat for good.

    The key is that Mike focuses on the REAL techniques that are going to get you lasting results, and teaches you how to avoid all of these "quick-fix" scams and gimmicks that are all over the infomercials and the internet these days.

    Several of the mistakes that Mike see's every day where people are going wrong in their fat loss attempts are:

    1. Most people are wasting too much of their time doing hundreds of reps of ineffective crunches, situps, and other "abs pumping" exercises in their attempt at losing stomach fat.
    Mike has discovered that there are certain highly effective exercises that stimulate your metabolism much better, and increase your fat burning hormone levels much more. These exercises that Mike outlines are the best of the best for getting a lean, chiseled body.

    Surprisingly to most, the majority of these most effective exercises for stomach fat loss are NOT "abs-specific" exercises. Not only that, but Mike shows you how to combine and sequence them to get the best metabolic and fat loss results possible, changing the shape of your entire body.

    2. Most people are wasting way too much time doing hours upon hours of boring monotonous cardio routines.

    Mike has researched this topic extensively, including an entire course he's taken comparing different modalities of cardiovascular exercise. After all of this research, we've come to the conclusion that the majority of people out there are not doing the right types of cardio exercise. In fact, most people may actually be inadvertantly decreasing their metabolic rate by doing too much of the wrong types of cardio!

    The strategies that Mike reveals in his program go beyond "interval cardio" too.

    3. Most people are failing miserably with fad diets.

    Mike reveals exactly why most low-carb or low-fat diets are actually working against what your body needs to become lean and ripped and maintain it for life! Mike shows you exactly how to stop falling for the gimmick diets and finally develop a truly healthy eating style that you can actually enjoy for life without being overly restrictive. It's actually easier and more enjoyable than you believe!

    Go to Mike's Truth about Six Pack Abs site today and discover the exact system that Mike is using to help thousands of his clients from all over the world get leaner than they've ever been before. This system will help you to lose that stubborn stomach fat that has plagued you for years, so you can finally get that sexy six pack that you've always wanted.

    Here's the: Secrets for losing stubborn stomach fat.

    Don't forget to visit Mike's site today, as he's giving away some great free bonus reports and other tools that might not be available much longer.

    To being lean, strong, and healthy for life,

    Sign off.

    ReplyDelete
  7. So is possible that HIV Disease can be cured because I have been scammed so many times not until I came across this great man Dr Akhigbe who helped me at first I never believe all this comment and post about him and I was very sick because I have been infected with HIV/AIDS for the past two year,just last 2 months I keep reading the testimony about this man named Dr Akhigbe they said that the man is so powerful he have cured different type of diseases, I keep monitoring his post of some people about this man and I found out that he was real so I decided to give him a trial I contacted him for help and he said he was going to help me get my cure that all I needed to do was to send him money to prepare the medication after which it will be sent to me via DHL courier delivery services which I did to my greatest surprise the medication was sent to me he gave me instructions to follow on how to drink it that after  three weeks I should go for check up,after taking the medicine and follow his instruction after three weeks I went back to the hospital for another test, at first I was shocked when the doctor told me that I was  negative I ask the doctor to check again and the result was still the same negative that was how I free from  HIV VIRUS at of the shock I decided to come and share my own testimony with you for those who think there is no cure for HIV VIRUS the cure as finally come'  out stop doubting and contact Dr Akhigbe via email drrealakhigbe@gmail.com he will help you out you can also whatsApp him via +2348142454860 he is also perfect in curing DIABETICS,HERPES,HIV/AIDS, ;ALS,  CANCER ,HEPATITIS A AND B,ASTHMA, HEART DISEASE, CHRONIC DISEASE. NAUSEA VOMITING OR DIARRHEA,KIDNEY DISEASE, SPIDER BITE, SCHIZOPHRENIA, LUPUS,EXTERNAL INFECTION, COMMON COLD, PAIN IN JOINT,EPILEPSY,STROKE,STOMACH DISEASE. ECZEMA, EATING DISORDER etc believe me that deadly disease is not longer a deadly sentence because dr akhigbe has the cure.the godfather of herbal root.
    email: drrealakhigbe@gmail.com         whatsapp number.  +2348142454860  website: https://drrealakhigbe.weebly.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. I advise you to check https://admission-writer.com/blog/scholarship-essay-examples out if you want to read Scholarship Essay Examples. It will help you to achieve success

    ReplyDelete
  9. شركة نقل عفش بالرياض وجدة والدمام والخبر والجبيل اولقطيف والاحساء والرياض وجدة ومكة المدينة المنورة والخرج والطائف وخميس مشيط وبجدة افضل شركة نقل عفش بجدة نعرضها مجموعة الفا لنقل العفش بمكة والخرج والقصيم والطائف وتبوك وخميس مشيط ونجران وجيزان وبريدة والمدينة المنورة وينبع افضل شركات نقل الاثاث بالجبيل والطائف وخميس مشيط وبريدة وعنيزو وابها ونجران المدينة وينبع تبوك والقصيم الخرج حفر الباطن والظهران
    شركة نقل عفش بجدة
    شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة
    شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض
    شركة نقل عفش بالدمام
    شركة نقل عفش بالطائف
    شركة نقل عفش بمكة
    شركة نقل عفش بينبع

    ReplyDelete

Add a comment. Registration required because trolls.